American Heritage MagazineMay/June 1991    Volume 42, Issue 3
EDITORS’ BOOKSHELF
 

At Home

The American Family, 1750-1870
by Elisabeth Donaghy Garrett; Harry N. Abrams, Inc.; 304 pages; $49.50.

Brick buildings in early America were inevitably painted bright yellow or red with every seam precisely outlined in white. Kitchen and bedroom floors were often decorated with beach sand swirled with a broom. Someone trying to read a book by candlelight might have to snuff out the wick forty times per hour to keep it from guttering and going out. When George Washington lay ill in New York, residents chained off the streets nearest his home and spread adjacent streets with straw so that he wouldn’t be disturbed by the racket of passing carriages. When Louis Philippe, soon to be king of France, traveled through the South in 1797, he found that “nowhere are there chamber pots; we asked for one at Mr. J. Campbell’s and were told that there were broken panes in the windows.”

These and a thousand other insights, great and small, make up At Home. Using two hundred paintings, prints, and drawings—half of them reproduced in color—and drawing on letters, household inventories, advertisements, novels, and poetry, Mrs. Garrett presents a wonderfully detailed and vivid portrait of how houses were decorated, kept clean, and lived in before the age of modern conveniences. In her research she discovered eloquent commentators to help tell her tale. Those white-bordered bricks, according to Lydia Maria Child, were “as numerous as Protestant sects, and as unlovely in their narrowness.” And in August the sun beat back from the bright red walls “like the shining face of a heated cook.”


 

Redcoats and Rebels

The American Revolution Through British Eyes
by Christopher Hibbert; W. W. Norton & Co.; 375 pages; $29.95.

The British historian Christopher Hibbert has made a career of writing books that are highly readable, informative, and accessible. This is one of the reasons for his unpopularity among academic historians. He is treading on their turf and having a good time doing it. Not for him is the dusty tone endemic to many professional scholars. Like the late A. J. P. Taylor, he flies in the face of the Oxbridge establishment, pulling the odd beard and upsetting the occasional household god by Grafting carefully reasoned histories that both entertain and reward the amateur historian. In his latest book, Redcoats and Rebels, Hibbert makes no pretenses about his aims: “This is a narrative history … intended for the general reader rather than the student, although I hope the student to whom the field is new may find it a useful introduction.”

And indeed it is. However, it is also more. Hibbert has successfully rendered a compact history of the American Revolution that would be of use to even the most devout history buff. He gives us the view from London: the gossip in the coffeehouses and clubs lining St. James’s, the reluctance among senior army officers to leave the comforts of home, and the unwillingness of the king and his treasury to pay for the supplies and men that were needed to win a war. Hibbert portrays the British not as a nation of bellicose lobster-backs but rather as the frustrated and frequently apathetic warriors and statesmen that they were.

Mr. Hibbert continues to write history as well as his critics only wish they could. No wonder he annoys them so much.