Search 
     
 
 Most Popular Searches:  Subscription | Immigration | Great Depression | Florida Sites | Elvis Presley  
 
American Heritage MagazineOctober 1998    Volume 49, Issue 6
Browse Archives

Browse our American Heritage Magazine issues from 1954 to the present.

Archives >>

 
 
 
 
 

The American Heritage


40 A ranking of the forty wealthiest Americans of all time (Surprise: Only three of them are alive today)
COMPILED BY MICHAEL KLEPPER AND ROBERT GUNTHER
BIOGRAPHIES BY JEANETTE BAIK, LINDA BARTH, AND CHRISTINE GIBSON


JOHN D. ROCKEFELLER

1839-1937

After graduating from high school in 1855, he worked as a bookkeeper and clerk in Cleveland, Ohio. Amid the Allegheny oil boom of the 1860s, his dealings in commodities led naturally to refining and an operation that in 1870 emerged as Standard Oil, of which he was named president. It was at first only one of many small outfits, but under his aegis it absorbed most of its competitors, and by 1881 it controlled about 90 percent of the nation’s oil business, benefiting from what many considered unfair advantages, such as railroad rebates. In 1882 Standard Oil invented the trust to get around laws against owning businesses in more than one state; in 1892 the Standard Oil trust was theoretically broken up as an illegal monopoly, but it survived until 1911 by the rise of another novelty, the holding company. Rockefeller retired in 1897. By 1922 he had given away about a billion dollars to family members and charity and kept only about twenty million for himself.


ANDREW CARNEGIE

1835-1919

In 1848 the twelve-year-old Carnegie emigrated with his impoverished Scottish family to the United States. He began working for the Pennsylvania Railroad as a telegrapher and rose to be its superintendent of military transportation during the Civil War; he resigned in 1865 to pursue his own opportunities. After 1873 he concentrated on steel and built an empire that controlled every aspect of its manufacture; by the turn of the century, his mills produced more steel than all of Great Britain. In 1901 he sold it all to the newly formed United States Steel Corporation, retired completely, and became a megaphilanthropist, distributing almost all his fortune to build public libraries and establish a number of foundations and educational and research institutions.


CORNELIUS VANDERBILT

1794-1877

At sixteen he bought his first sailing vessel to ferry passengers and produce between his native Staten Island and New York City; in 1829 he started a steamship line. He set his rates so low that his rivals either had to pay him to avoid their routes or had to sell out to him. During the gold rush his faster, cheaper passage from New York to San Francisco captured most of the traffic. Foreseeing American shipping’s decline, he abruptly sold his fleet in the early 1860s to concentrate on railways; he eventually got hold of the Hudson River Railroad and the New York Central and combined them and acquired the Lake Shore &C Michigan Southern to establish a through route between New York and Chicago in 1873. He passed on most of his fortune to his son, William H.


JOHN JACOB ASTOR

1763-1848

He started out in the fur business as a clerk but quickly moved on to work for himself. Exchanging American furs for European firearms and musical instruments, by the 1820s he had built up the largest fur-trading business in the United States. When the government asked its wealthiest citizens to help fund the War of 1812, he did his part—clearly to his advantage, paying only eighty-eight cents on the dollar for two million dollars’ worth of government bonds. When the fur business began to wane, he coolly sold out and refocused on his already flourishing real estate investments, buying up lots in the desolate northern part of Manhattan and gambling that the growing city would catch up. It did.


WILLIAM H. GATES III

1955-

From the moment he saw his private school’s primitive computer, he was obsessed. Programming jobs for Seattle-area companies soon followed, and by the time he was twenty-one he had dropped out of Harvard, licensed a compiler for BASIC to the manufacturers of the first microcomputer, and cofounded Microsoft. Microsoft vaulted forward in 1980, when IBM asked it to design an operating system, MS-DOS; during the eighties the blockbuster programs Excel, Word, and Windows followed. Vital to Microsoft’s success has been Gates’s ruthless competitive edge, honed from youth at family pickleball tournaments and jigsawpuzzle-assembling races; the federal government’s on-again, off-again antitrust battles with his company have raged since 1990.


STEPHEN GIRARD

1750-1831

At fourteen he got a job as a cabin boy on a trading voyage to Haiti; he quickly rose to be part owner of a ship and then to develop a fleet that traded to the West Indies, Europe, and Asia. His care and resource in directing his ships through waters troubled first by the French Revolution and then by the Napoleonic Wars amassed him a fortune, and around the turn of the century he shifted his attention to real estate, insurance, and banking. During the War of 1812 he averted a financial crisis with the help of John Jacob Astor (No. 4) by underwriting most of a war loan to the government.


A. T. STEWART

1803-1876

With a five-thousand-dollar inheritance, this Scotch-Irish immigrant set up a small dry goods shop in New York in 1823. He outgrew several locations, built a lavish “Marble Palace,” outgrew that, and built an even more spectacular eight-story-tall “Iron Palace,” which became the world’s largest retail store when it opened in 1862. His stores were among the first to offer fixed prices, and they attracted the wealthy and fashionable. The bulk of his fortune, however, was gained through wholesaling and especially through heavy investments in New York City real estate. Dying without an heir, he left his fifty-million-dollar fortune to his wife, who passed control of it to his former attorney, who grossly mismanaged it. Two years later his coffin was stolen from the grave and successfully held for ransom.


FREDERICK WEYERHAEUSER

1834-1914

He emigrated to the United States from Germany in 1852 and several years later found a job at a sawmill in Rock Island, Illinois, where he worked his way up to foreman. With money he had saved he entered into a partnership with his brother-inlaw. It was a good time to be in the lumber business; the growing nation was gobbling up wood for construction and fuel. His company accumulated more and more acres of forestland until at his death in 1914 it owned more than two million acres across Wisconsin, Minnesota, and the Pacific Northwest.


JAY GOULD

1836-1892

A self-made man whose fortune really took off when he began to speculate in railroad stock, Gould routinely engaged in hard-handed market tactics, such as corners, pools, and bear raids. On September 24, 1869, his attempt to corner the gold market triggered Black Friday, ruining many investors. He turned to Western railroads, starting with holdings in the Union Pacific and the Kansas Pacific, and by 1890 he owned half the trackage in the Southwest. He also picked up the New York World, Western Union, and the New York elevated railways.


MARSHALL FIELD

1834-1906

Having started out as an errand boy at a dry goods store in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, by 1865 he was a partner in an established Chicago dry goods house. By 1881 he had bought out his two partners and renamed the business Marshall Field and Company, and by 1895, despite several severe setbacks, the store was grossing forty million dollars a year. He made up the slogan “The customer is always right,” and he introduced openly displayed prices, liberal credit, and the ability to return merchandise (and was first to put a restaurant in a store); he also knew how to both anticipate and create consumer demand.


SAM WALTON

1918-1992

The only member of this list ever to hula down Wall Street in a grass skirt—he did so after losing a bet to his employees that they couldn’t raise their pretax profits above 8 percent—Walton was a small-time shopkeeper who invented the superstore as the most efficient way to serve rural communities. His stores profited not only by serving places that others overlooked but also by employing innovative inventory-control techniques, using computers to monitor all the stock everywhere, and making all the stores satellites of warehouses within a day’s drive. His shelves were never empty of anything for more than a few hours, he negotiated directly with manufacturers to keep his costs low, and he always took care of his employees—even if it meant dancing down Wall Street.


HENRY FORD

1863-1947

The son of Anglo-Irish immigrants, Ford began building an automobile while employed as a machinist for the Edison Illuminating Company in Detroit; he presented his Quadricycle in 1896. In 1901 he entered a racer of his own design in a ten-mile match race and won, then persuaded investors to back the formation of the Ford Motor Company in 1903. In 1908 he introduced the sturdy and affordable Model T, and he constantly lowered its price, from $850 in 1908 down to $290 by the midtwenties, believing that greater volume would make up for the lower profit margin. He was right: By 1914 the company was selling 248,000 Model T’s a year, capturing close to 50 percent of the market. But he kept it in production far too long, nearly sinking the company before switching to the Model A in 1927.


WARREN BUFFETT

1930-

After learning at the knee of the Columbia Graduate School of Business professor Benjamin Graham, the “oracle of Omaha” scraped together a hundred thousand dollars to start an investment partnership when he was twenty-five; it had increased its clients’ money an average of 30 percent a year when it was dissolved in 1969. By then Buffett had bought the small, worn-down textile firm Berkshire Hathaway; as a holding company it acquired undervalued companies whose stock values grew, and it is today a multibilliondollar powerhouse that owns stock in the Washington Post, Coca-Cola, American Express, and Capital Cities/ABC. Buffett retains a self-deprecating sense of humor and modesty: He does his own taxes, drives his own car, and says that Berkshire’s stock is overvalued.

 


ANDREW W. MELLON

1855-1937


RICHARD B. MELLON

1858-1933

When he was nineteen, Andrew joined his father’s bank, T. Mellon & Sons; his younger brother Richard came aboard as a partner after their father’s retirement in 1886. Thanks to their complementary personalities, they enjoyed a warm—and effective —family and business partnership. Andrew managed the books while Richard met with customers. Pittsburgh, where they did business, was the center of booming coal, steel, oil, and railroad industries. They had a keen eye for promising business ventures and backed a number of companies that became industrial giants, among them the Aluminum Company of America, Gulf Oil, and Union Steel. In 1921 President Harding appointed Andrew Secretary of the Treasury; his eleven-year tenure brought about a dramatic reduction in the national debt. In 1937 Andrew donated his impressive art collection, plus money for a building to house it, to create the National Gallery of Art. Richard’s passion was reviving rundown Pittsburgh.


JAMES G. FAIR

1831-1894

This Irish immigrant failed to strike it rich mining in California and Nevada, so he set up a lumber business to serve prospectors on the Comstock Lode. In the 187Os he and a group of associates got control of a property near Virginia City, Nevada, and in 1873 the resulting Consolidated Virginia Mine produced enough silver to potentially destabilize the U.S. money supply. Fair converted his share of the wealth into railroads, buildings, land, and high living. He served a six-year Senate term but was better known for his family’s sad decline: Divorced, alienated from his children, he died alone. He stipulated in his will that anyone able to prove themself to be his widow or child would be entitled to fifty dollars.


WILLIAM WEIGHTMAN

1813-1904

He emigrated from England at sixteen at the urging of an uncle who owned a chemical-manufacturing company in Philadelphia and became its chemist; after the deaths of his uncle and his partner, he took over the business. The predecessor of the modern pharmaceutical company, it was the first to develop and manufacture cheap and effective substitutes for quinine to treat malaria, and it also pioneered the manufacture of citric acid, both a food flavoring and an ingredient in metal polish. He invested conservatively, primarily in land, and became the largest real estate owner in Philadelphia. He was intensely private and shunned society in favor of spending time at home, tending his garden of rare flowers.


MOSES TAYLOR

1806-1882

Growing up surrounded by wealth—his father was John Jacob Astor’s confidential agent—he was determined to earn his own. In 1832 he used $15,000 he had saved to open his own import business, which he left in 1855 to become the president of City Bank. During the Panic of 1857 he bought controlling interest, for $5 a share, in the ailing Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad; he appeared to have been swept away by his passion for railroads, but seven years later it was trading at $240 a share. His contemporaries regarded his intimate knowledge of his investments as his greatest asset, but he built his lasting reputation on his sense of civic duty: He organized and chaired the committee of bankers that kept the Union solvent during the Civil War.


RUSSELL SAGE

1816-1906

He seems to have become one of the wealthiest people in American history simply by being in the right place at the right time. His early investments made him comfortable, but a chance meeting with the roundly despised Jay Gould made him rich beyond his dreams. Gould became his friend and ally, and under Gould’s aegis he made a fortune in the stock market, where he is credited with originating puts and calls. He preferred small returns to big risks, and he eventually turned to moneylending; at one time he was purported to have twenty-seven million dollars out on loan. Luck was apparently ever on his side; he survived an assassin’s bomb that killed his clerk and the assassin and died quietly at home.


JOHN I. BLAIR

1802-1899

As a ten-year-old farm boy in New Jersey he supposedly told his mother, “I have seven brothers and three sisters. That’s enough in the family to be educated. I am going to get rich.” He dropped out of school at eleven to work as a clerk and within seven years had opened his own store. He began in mining, forming the Lackawanna Coal & Iron Company, but made his fortune in railroads. With a little help from political connections, he and some colleagues chartered the Union Pacific, which built the eastern half of the transcontinental railroad and became infamous for its owners’ business practices. At one time he served as president of sixteen railroads simultaneously, had enough acreage to cover half of New Jersey, and personally owned more track than anyone else in the world.


CYRUS CURTIS

1850-1933

He left school at sixteen after his family’s house burned down and eventually made his way into the newspaper business. In 1879 he started the Tribune and farmer, which included a column for women written by his wife; the column was so successful that he spun it into Ladies’ Home Journal, whose circulation rose to two hundred thousand in its first year and a half. He bought The Saturday Evening Post in 1897 for a thousand dollars and had raised its circulation from two thousand to more than 2.7 million by the time of his death. He complemented a genius for marketing to the average American with a willingness to pay the highest prices for stories by writers like Mark Twain and Louisa May Alcott.


PAUL G. ALLEN

1953-

This whiz kid was blessed with both an interest in computers and being a high school classmate of Bill Gates (No. 5)— though perhaps Gates was blessed with being his classmate too. He dropped out of Washington State to go to work for Honeywell before joining Gates in 1975 to found Microsoft, which took off in the early 1980s. He retired from active involvement in Microsoft in 1983 after learning that he had Hodgkin’s disease, from which he later recovered, but he is still the company’s second-largest stockholder. He also owns, among other things, the Seattle Seahawks football team and the Portland Trail Blazers basketball team.


JOHN PIERPONT MORGAN

1837-1913

A famously imposing man, he showed his mettle at twenty-one, when he enraged his employers by buying a shipload of coffee without their authorization and then turned out to have sold the entire cargo at a healthy profit before it had even arrived at the dock. He was born rich, but he made his own fortune along with a reputation as the most powerful, dependable, and forthright man on Wall Street, underwriting the creation of such corporations as General Electric, International Harvester, and U.S. Steel. He was actually powerful far out of proportion to his wealth; during the Panic of 1907 he averted national disaster by raising twenty-five million dollars in fifteen minutes and single-handedly keeping the Stock Exchange from closing early. Within twelve hours of his death, while vacationing in Rome, his family received 3,698 telegrams of condolence.


EDWARD HENRY HARRIMAN

1848-1909

Never one to waste time, he left school at fourteen to begin his career and by twentyone had purchased a seat on the New York Stock Exchange. Using the money he made on Wall Street, he worked his way into railroads, which were his passion. By 1898 he was chairman of the executive committee of the Union Pacific and he ruled without dissent. But he speculated heavily with Union Pacific holdings, and his attempt to monopolize the Chicago rail market led to the Panic of 1901. He dreamed of building an around-the-world railroad that would cross the Bering Strait as his legacy.


HENRY HUDDLESTON ROGERS

1840-1909

He started out as a paperboy in Massachusetts and later was a railroad baggageman. As soon as he had saved six hundred dollars, he headed for the newly discovered oil fields of Pennsylvania. His success in investing there led the oilman Charles Pratt to invite him to join his Brooklyn firm. There he invented a machine that could separate the solvent naphtha from crude oil. Standard Oil took over Pratt’s company in 1874, and its officers eventually made Rogers vice president. He was a brilliant inventor, a ruthless businessman, a philanthropist, and, in an odd twist, Mark Twain’s business manager.


OLIVER HAZARD PAYNE

1839-1917

The son of a successful industrialist and politician, he studied at Yale before enlisting in the Union Army in 1861. After the war he invested in the iron industry and then in the new field of oil refining, and his company was the first to be acquired by John D. Rockefeller’s Standard Oil. When the Standard Oil trust was formed, he was made one of its nine trustees and served as its Washington lobbyist. He was charged with bribing the Ohio legislature to get his father a Senate seat and with paying off the Democratic party to have his brother-in-law named Secretary of the Navy; the charges were later dropped. He went on to help in the formation of U.S. Steel.


HENRY CLAY FRICK

1849-1919

As chairman of Carnegie Brothers he would rise at six in the morning, walk two miles to work, and stay at his desk until six in the evening. That work ethic paid off early. At twenty-one, while serving as a bookkeeper in his grandfather’s distillery, he and some friends pooled their limited resources and built coke ovens in the surrounding Pennsylvania coal country. By age forty-one he had sold his majority share of the resulting empire to Andrew Carnegie and was chairman of Carnegie’s steel company. He survived being both shot and stabbed by an anarchist during a strike at Carnegie’s Homestead, Pennsylvania, plant—he insisted on telegraphing Andrew Carnegie in Scotland on the status of the strike before seeking medical treatment.


COLLIS POTTER HUNTINGTON

1821-1900

Once described as “a hard & cheery man, with no more soul than a shark,” he worked his way up from poverty as a Sacramento merchant before the engineer Theodore Judah came to him proposing the impossible: a transcontinental railroad. Quick to spot an opportunity, he joined with Mark Hopkins, Leland Stanford, and Charles Crocker—they became known as the “Big Four”—to incorporate in June 1861 the Central Pacific Railroad. It built east from California until meeting up with Union Pacific, which built west from Omaha. Of the Big Four, notorious for their dubious business practices (they scammed an estimated thirtysix million dollars on the project), he was perhaps the most audacious: He hired geologists to prove that the Sierra Nevada began twenty-two miles before the first foothills.


PETER A. WIDENER

1834-1915

A groundbreaker of nineteenth-century consolidation, he knotted together all the street railways in Philadelphia and then helped assemble American Tobacco, U.S. Steel, and the International Mercantile Marine Company. He held his first job in a meat shop, won a contract to supply mutton to all the Civil War troops within ten miles of Philadelphia, and invested his fifty-thousanddollar profit, plus money he earned holding local political offices, in street railways and Philadelphia traction companies. Under his eye, Philadelphia streetcar technology advanced from horse to cable to electric, and his money and expertise helped build lines in New York and Chicago as well.


NICHOLAS LONGWORTH

1782-1863

Patriots confiscated all the property belonging to his Loyalist family during the American Revolution, and perhaps that goaded him to set out to make his millions in land trade. Starting out in law, he traded his very first fee—two secondhand copper stills—for thirty-three acres of land later worth $2 million. He then bought his boss’s cow pasture for $5,000; its worth grew to $1.5 million under his ownership. His real estate deals brought him great wealth, but he carved a more lasting mark as a leader in a far less lucrative field, horticulture. He introduced new types of strawberry and black raspberry to America, and his experiments greatly boosted this nation’s fruit production.


PHILIP DANFORTH ARMOUR

1832-1901

Returning home from the gold rush at twenty-four with several thousand dollars in his pocket, he turned to meatpacking, and near the end of the Civil War he found a way to turn meat into gold, selling pork futures at forty dollars a barrel and then buying the pork for eighteen dollars after the Confederacy collapsed. With the nearly two-million-dollar profit that resulted, he built Armour & Company. He was one of the first to bring hogs to Chicago for slaughter at his own plant, and he cut waste by using leftovers to make glue, soap, and fertilizer. Hurt by the 189899 meat scandals that inspired Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle, he gave away perhaps half his fortune.


JAMES C. FLOOD

1826-1889

He went to California and became one of the few forty-niners who actually made their fortunes in gold. Then he went on to Nevada, where as one of a foursome (other members: James G. Fair [No. 16], John Mackay, and William O’Brien) he operated three thousand feet of the rich Comstock Lode and co-owned the Consolidated Virginia and California mines; they doled out a hundred million dollars to stockholders between 1874 and 1879. He and James Fair ran the Bank of Nevada and owned Virginia City’s sawmills. They once dared a New York Tribune correspondent to ride a boat with them down a breakneck mile-long log flume, built to carry lumber. “I would not make the trip again for the whole Consolidated Virginia Mine,” Flood remarked afterward.


MARK HOPKINS

1813-1878

A quiet, reasonable man, he does not jump out of the history books as do his partners in the Central Pacific Railroad, but as its treasurer, working behind the scenes, he provided the levelheaded business sense that made the other three extremely rich: Two are on this list; the other, Charles Crocker, missed by only two places. Lured to California by gold, he soon figured he could make more money supplying miners and opened an iron and hardware store with Collis Huntington (No. 28). It was in the apartment over that store that an engineer persuaded the soon-to-be Big Four to finance what would become the Central Pacific.


EDWARD CLARK

1811-1882

He had been practicing law for more than twenty years when Isaac Singer offered him a share in his thriving sewing-machine business in return for representation in a patent-infringement suit. Clark disapproved of Singer’s sexual escapades and egotism but recognized the chance to earn a fortune. He defended the company tenaciously, eventually organizing the first American patent pool for it. He pioneered the idea of installment buying, and he used nationwide demonstrations to persuade the public that the machine was easy to use. When Singer died in 1875, Clark took over as president and ran the company for the rest of his life.


LELAND STANFORD

1824-1893

When he swung at the golden spike at the completion of the transcontinental railway on May 10, 1869, he was crowning a venture that had taken eight years, surviving sixty-foot snowdrifts, dangerously rough terrain, and deserting workers. He missed- perhaps the only time in his life he failed to strike gold. He had gone to California in 1852 after a fire destroyed his Wisconsin law office; he sold miners’ supplies and raked in a fortune. Elected governor of California in 1861, he approved four public grants totaling well over a million dollars for the transcontinental line, lining his own pockets since he was already president of the Central Pacific. When his fifteen-year-old son died in 1884, he founded California’s great Leland Stanford, Jr., University in tribute.


HETTY GREEN

1834-1916

Social norms being what they were, the list’s only woman was called the Witch of Wall Street in her day, but she contributed to that reputation too. After inheriting $7.5 million at the age of thirty and making the most of several bull markets—largely in railroads and real estate—she still wore dowdy, inexpensive clothes and once spent hours searching for a two-cent stamp she had dropped. Raised in a New Bedford Quaker family, she learned business on the wharves of her grandfather’s shipping firm. “There is no great secret in fortune making,” she once said. “All you have to do is buy cheap and sell dear, act with thrift and shrewdness and be persistent.”


JAMES J. HILL

1838-1916

The Canadian son of Irish immigrants, he started out as a two-dollar-a-day laborer for a steamboat company in St. Paul and within a decade had his own fleet. In 1873 he persuaded the stockholders of the decrepit St. Paul & Pacific Railroad to sell out to him and his partners; he planned to extend the line to the Pacific. “HiIPs folly” reached Puget Sound by 1893 without any public subsidies, thriving on low grades, low cost, and skilled management. He enticed new residents into the area to ensure his railroad’s success, and his renamed Great Northern outlived bad economies that withered other railroads. To reach Chicago, he (with the help of J. P. Morgan [No. 23]) snatched the Northern Pacific and Chicago, Burlington & Quincy from under the nose of E. H. Harriman (No. 24), sparking a lifelong rivalry.


WILLIAM ROCKEFELLER

1841-1922

The younger, more gregarious brother of John D. Rockefeller (No. 1), he served as president of Standard Oil of New York, putting to work his considerable salesmanship skills to acquire refiners, pipelines, oil fields, and shipping lines. -When the Supreme Court dissolved Standard Oil in 1911, he went on to close numerous Wall Street deals as an officer of the National City Bank. Unlike his philanthropist brother, he kept secret what few gifts he gave.


ELIAS HASKET DERBY

1739-1799

Without ever going to sea, he applied his thorough understanding of ship design and geography to the prosperous merchant business he inherited, making himself rich and turning Salem, Massachusetts, into a major international seaport. All but one of his ships returned safely, largely because he chose for his crews the best men available and promised them a hefty slice of the profits. His ships were the first from New England to reach the Orient.


CLAUS SPRECKELS

1828-1908

A German-born immigrant, he got into sugar in 1863 at the urging of his brother, with whom he established the Bay Sugar Refining Company in San Francisco. In 1867, after studying sugar manufacture in Europe, he built the California Sugar Refinery, which within five years was putting out fifty million pounds annually. He eventually had a monopoly in West Coast sugar, but a six-year family feud wrested away some of his empire late in his life.

 
How Did They Do It?
The lessons of their success
BY JOHN STEELE GORDON

Imagine the uproar that would ensue if a columnist for The New York Times—one of the most prestigious posts in American journalism—were to include in a column a flat-out bigoted statement of the all-X-are-Y variety. Fortunately we have reached a point in this country where it is almost inconceivable that such a statement would appear in such a venue.

Or have we?

“In business, of course,” Bob Herbert wrote in The New York Times on November 21, 1993, “it is dollars above all. If you have to step over corpses to collect your cash, so be it. Money excuses everything.” In other words, all businesspeople are money-mad and ruthless. Now Mr. Herbert surely did not mean to say that his own employers—who try their level best to see to it that the New York Times Company is as profitable as possible—would step over dead bodies to maximize that profit. But that is exactly what he did say, by converting an ugly stereotype into a universal truth.

Let me be clear, I am not saying that Mr. Herbert is a bigot. Far from it. I have no doubt that—to alter slightly a notorious phrase —some of his best friends are businessmen. The problem lies in the fact that his image of the businessmen he knows and admires is at serious odds with his image of businessmen in general, and he has not yet had his consciousness raised regarding that fact.

That image of the businessman was formed at the turn of the century, when Americans were piling up fortunes of unprecedented scale in the Industrial Revolution and the left was a rising force in American politics, calling for increased government supervision of business. Such historians as Ida Tarbell, Gustavus Meyers, Upton Sinclair, and Matthew Josephson depicted all these men as ruthless, diabolical, power-mad automatons of greed. Cartoonists depicted them as top-hatted, pig-snouted, moneybag-bodied manipulators of politicians and the public. Christian preachers, the heirs to two thousand years of animosity to “moneychangers,” warned against excessive worship of the false god Mammon.

To give an example of just how intellectually dishonest some of these people were, consider a quote from Matthew Josephson’s The Robber Barons, a book first published in 1934 and in print ever since. “In seeking quickened activity, great volume and lower prices—instead of honest but limited services at high tariffs—he [Cornelius Vanderbilt] gave intimations of a new personal departure from the older bourgeois order.” Isn’t that neat? Josephson manages to make Commodore Vanderbilt look dishonest for offering the public cheap, safe, convenient transportation and making a fortune on the resulting high volume.

Compare this with what Vanderbilt’s contemporaries thought of his deeds. When he died, on January 4, 1877, The New York Times, then, as now, no cheering section for plutocrats (it was, in fact, the first to apply the image, if not the term, of the “robber baron” to men such as Vanderbilt), wrote in an editorial: “His one foible of opposition was an immense boon to the public, for wherever his keen eyes detected a monopoly he pounced down upon the offenders and literally drove them from the rivers. Nor did he, when he had vanquished them, establish a monopoly of his own. His principle of low rates, founded upon acute reasoning, was never violated, so that in every way the public were the gainers. . . . Commodore Vanderbilt never stopped improving, but went on developing, maturing and ripening his system until death called him away from the scene where he had reigned so long without equal.”

In many ways we have come as far from the days of Ida Tarbell and her ilk as Ron Chernow’s new and altogether splendid biography of John D. Rockefeller, Titan, is from her tendentious 1904 History of the Standard Oil Company. But the image created a century ago lingers on. For instance, a sizable fraction of the murders depicted in prime-time entertainment shows on network television are committed by businessmen. If there has ever been a movie in which a businessman was a hero, I am unaware of it.

Yet some of them were heroes. Stephen Girard and J. P. Morgan both came to the rescue of the federal government itself in times of extreme financial distress.

Charles Schwab, controlling stockholder of the Bethlehem Steel Corporation during World War I (he doesn’t make the top forty because he later lost his fortune), was offered one hundred million dollars by the Germans for his shares in the corporation, so that its productive capacities could be withheld from the British. It was far more than the market price and would have made Schwab in a stroke one of the richest men in the world. But he turned them down out of hand and told the British that their contracts would be fulfilled to the letter and ahead of schedule. Adm. Lord Fisher, the father of the modern Royal Navy and First Sea Lord at the outbreak of the war, wrote in his autobiography, “If any man deserves the gratitude of England Mr. Schwab does.”

Andrew Carnegie gave away virtually his entire fortune before he died, including the money for building more than two thousand public libraries in the United States, Canada, Britain, and France so that a poor child, such as he had once been, could get the education needed to prosper in the modern world.

Equally, of course, many of the super rich were anything but heroes. Russell Sage, who left a fortune estimated at seventy million dollars when he died in 1906, rarely gave to charity and regularly helped himself to pencils, pads, and other useful items at board meetings. When a fellow board member, J. P. Morgan, tried to embarrass him into stopping this pilfering, the only result was a temper tantrum. Too cheap to hire a cab, when he tried to leap aboard a moving trolley, missed his footing, and fell to the street (he was eighty-six at the time), Sage sued the trolley company. (Sage was one of only two of the forty richest to serve in Congress; the other was James G. Fair. Sage “did nothing in particular and did it very well.” Fair’s time in the Senate was largely spent dealing with one of the most spectacular divorce cases of the nineteenth century, which began when he was accused by his wife of “habitual adultery” and ended when he paid her a then-awesome five million dollars in settlement. In between, needless to say, was a gossip-column feeding frenzy. I can only add that Sage and Fair certainly had terrific names for politicians.)

Hetty Green, the sole woman to make the list, had a genius for making money and a mortal terror of being without it. Her son lost his leg to an infection when she delayed treatment while she searched for a free doctor to care for him.

Indeed, if this list of the forty richest Americans proves anything—other than the indisputable fact that this country is now and always has been a great place to make a buck—it is that those who create titanic fortunes are every bit as varied, quirky, good, bad, self-contradictory, immoral, and sublime as the rest of us.

Just look at No. 1 and No. 3 on this list, John D. Rockefeller and Cornelius Vanderbilt. Both began poor; both died immensely, legendarily rich. Both were superb corporate managers who never stopped looking for ways to run their companies better and more cheaply than they had been run before. Both had strong, moral mothers, whom they adored, and weak fathers, whom they did not care for.

But there the resemblance stops. John D. Rockefeller’s father was a flimflam man; Vanderbilt’s, merely unambitious. Vanderbilt’s mother, while uninterested in religion and by no means opposed to enjoying life, used the Bible to inculcate a strong sense of right and wrong in her son, while Rockefeller’s mother was dour and devoted to the Baptist faith, which she taught her son from his earliest days.

As a result, Rockefeller seems to have looked on life as an obligation while Vanderbilt saw it as an opportunity. Rockefeller did not drink, smoke, or play cards. Vanderbilt did all three. Rockefeller was devoted to his wife and children and attended church faithfully. Vanderbilt was nearly indifferent to his family and never went near a church if he could help it.

Yet both were honest men, who could be completely relied upon to keep a bargain once they had agreed to it. ”. . . the Commodore’s word is as good as his bond when it is freely given,” wrote his contemporary Matthew Hale Smith (both a lawyer and a Congregational minister). “He is equally exact in fulfilling his threats.” The very same words could be applied to Rockefeller as well.

Or consider Rockefeller and his closest associate at Standard Oil, Henry Plagier. Their complementary business talents—Rockefeller was the detail man, the bean counter; Plagier, the idea man—made them a formidable combination in the office and close friends. “It was,” wrote Rockefeller, “a friendship founded on business, which Mr. Plagier used to say was a good deal better than a business founded on friendship.”

Outside the office, however, they had little in common. It is hard to imagine John D. Rockefeller even attending a large party (and altogether impossible to imagine him enjoying himself at one). But Plagier loved parties, and he often threw lavish ones, including an annual costume ball that more than once he attended in full drag (complete with cookie-duster mustache and everpresent cigar).

Even with regard to a sense of humor, the very rich vary quite as much as the rest of us. Some—the ever-generous Peter Cooper (not in the top forty), for instance—did not have one at all. Others have been richly endowed. Nicholas Longworth, probably the richest man in Cincinnati in his time, habitually dressed so poorly that a passer-by, thinking him a beggar, dropped a quarter in his hat one day when Longworth took it off to mop his brow. “Thank you, Sir,” Longworth called after him. “I never earned a quarter so easily in my life.”

John Jacob Astor even enjoyed making fun of his own foibles, including his carefully restrained charitable instincts. One day when a man dropped by his office to solicit a contribution to some worthy cause, Astor grumpily wrote out a check. Looking at the paltry amount from the richest man in the country in some dismay, the man said that Astor’s son, William, had already given twice as much.

“Ah, well,” replied Astor, “but then William has a rich man for a father.”

When Cornelius Vanderbilt first took control of the Harlem Railroad in New York, he went to the terminal to look around and encountered a woman who did not have enough money to buy tickets for herself and her children. Vanderbilt told an employee to make up the difference and charge it to petty cash. The employee did so and asked the cause of her troubles. She replied that her husband was out of work and unable to find any.

“What?” asked the incredulous Commodore, overhearing this. “Can’t find work in New York? Your husband must be a fine specimen.” The woman explained that in fact her husband had been an employee of the Harlem Railroad and was let go without compensation when injured on the job.

“Then he’ll be my first pensioner,” responded the Commodore, who could often be spontaneously generous. But he couldn’t resist leaning over to the employee and whispering, "[And] I hope my last.”

But if these people were so varied, what characteristics united them in their ability to create great fortunes? Well, certainly one of them was luck, a handy attribute in any field of endeavor. When his boss was too busy one day, he sent the teenage Charles Schwab to deliver a daily report to Andrew Carnegie. Schwab made sure to make an impression on the great man, and by the time he was in his mid-thirties he was president of the Carnegie Steel Corporation.

John Jacob Astor landed in this country in Baltimore. He might well have stayed there had his older brother, who had come with the Hessian troops who fought in the Revolutionary War, not settled in New York. John Jacob followed him to New York and began investing in New York real estate. When the Erie Canal caused the city’s growth to explode, so did the Astor fortune. On his deathbed he was asked if he had any regrets. He is supposed to have replied that he regretted only not having bought all Manhattan.

But, of course, it takes a lot more than luck. One requirement, it seems, is a capacity for very hard work and great attention to detail. Asked his advice on how to make a great fortune, Andrew Carnegie replied, “Put all your eggs in one basket, and then WATCH THAT BASKET.”

Another maxim that has stood the creators of great fortunes in good stead is “The time to save money is when you have it.” By banking the profits in good times, men like Vanderbilt, Carnegie, and Rockefeller were able to take advantage of bad times to snap up bargains and enlarge their empires. By no means the least of Bill Gates’s instruments of power today is the twelve billion dollars that Microsoft—whose stock pays no dividends—has salted away in the bank, ready for instant use when opportunity knocks.

A lack of sentimentality is another important attribute of the creators of great fortunes. Henry Ford so loved his Model T that when its time had passed, after nearly two decades of awesome profits, he nearly ruined the Ford Motor Company by his insistence on keeping it in production. John Jacob Astor, on the other hand, had been in the fur business for fifty years when it began to decline in the early 183Os, and he sold out his interests without a second thought. Commodore Vanderbilt, too, made his fortune in a business, shipping, that was in serious decline toward the end of his life. Still, at nearly seventy, he sold out and moved into railroads, multiplying his fortune in the last fifteen years of his life.

None of these attributes, however, would in the long run be of much use with out a final one: courage. Rudyard Kipling admired the ability to “make one heap of all your winnings / And risk it on one turn of pitchand-toss.” He was writing about what it took to be a man, not a millionaire, but it applies all the more to the latter. Henry Plagier, who just misses being in the top forty, made a modest fortune in his youth and then went bankrupt in the salt business before making a vast fortune with Standard Oil. When John Jacob Astor learned that his largest investment, a furtrading post called (what else?) Astoria, in the Oregon wilderness, had been wiped out by the fortunes of war, he went to the theater that night anyway. When a friend expressed surprise at seeing him there, Astor merely answered, “What would you have me do? Would you have me stay at home and weep for what I cannot help?”

Of course, it must be added that the people who create great fortunes not only have courage but are also correct in their bets. The history of business is littered with the Chapter Seven petitions of those who bet wrong. Bob Herbert might consider that they, too, are businessmen.


 
An Astor Ball for All Time
How we chose the richest Americans
BY MICHAEL KLEPPER AND ROBERT GUNTHER

Who are the wealthiest Americans across all U.S. history? That question led us to begin a wideranging exploration that became our 1996 book The Wealthy 100: From Benjamin Franklin to Bill Gates—A Ranking of the Richest Americans, Past and Present. In it we ranked wealthy Americans since the start of the nation. Among the surprises was that George Washington (No. 59) and Ben Franklin (No. 86) turn up there. Throughout U.S. history there have been attempts to define the financial pecking order, from the lists of wealthy New Yorkers by Moses Yale Beach in the 1840s to the guest list of the annual 400-person Astor ball that later defined New York society and on to today’s systematic rankings in FORBES. Yet there had never been a list across the history of the nation.

The general concept of our ranking, here brought up to date, is simple: After estimating the size of each fortune at the time of death, or in the current year for living members of the list, we compared that fortune with the total gross national product (GNP) at the time. The ratio tells how the wealth of the individual compared with the total wealth of the entire nation. For example, Rockefeller’s fortune added up to about one sixty-fifth of the GNP, a record Bill Gates still has a long way to go to match. Finally, we have divided the wealth-to-GNP ratio into today’s GNP to come up with an equivalent fortune in today’s economy.

Beneath these simple formulas lies tremendous complexity. First of all, the official government figures for the’ GNP date back only to 1929, so we used estimates for earlier years; the GNP is admittedly a crude instrument, but other measures make even less sense when comparing the early post-Revolutionary War economy with today’s. Any way of comparing the value of money across eras when the meaning of money changed so much can be questioned, but the best yardstick we can produce must be better than none. Second, estimating the size of individual fortunes is also challenging. Their sizes were often masked by legend and braggadocio, not to mention more deliberate obfuscation. We did not count lost fortunes, but philanthropic gifts were added back in; to do otherwise would have seriously skewed the fortunes of Carnegie, Rockefeller, and others. We also did not include family fortunes, unless they were clearly the work of an individual.

If Caroline Astor—granddaughter-in-law of John Jacob Astor and founder of the Astor ball—were to open her ballroom again today, to a more intimate gathering of the very wealthiest Americans past and present, the American Heritage 40 might well represent the guest list. Everything they did was on the largest scale. If the ruthlessness and avarice of some of them was at times unsurpassed, so too was the magnitude of their generosity. Welcome to the party.

The Wealthy 100 was published by Citadel Press in 1996. Michael Klepper is the head of Michael Klepper and Associates in New York City, and Robert Gunther is the head of a communications firm in Kimberton, Pennsylvania.


 
 
Discuss this article  |  Print this article  |  Email this article
 
Related Articles
 
 

1870s STANDARD OIL
AH June 2001

 
 
 
 
E-Mail Newsletters
 
 

Get E-Mail Newsletters when we publish articles on any of the topics below:

ANDREW CARNEGIE
 
ANDREW WILLIAM MELLON
 
BOB HERBERT
 
BUSINESS
 
CHARLES SCHWAB
 
CHRISTINE M. GIBSON
 
CORNELIUS VANDERBILT
 
COURAGE
 
FREDERICK WEYERHAEUSER
 
GERMANY
 

Help

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Contact Us  |  Subscriber Services  |  Terms and Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  Site Map  |  Newsroom  |  HeritageSites.com  
 

American History from AmericanHeritage.com. Copyright 2008 American Heritage Publishing. All rights reserved.