Skip to main content

From Mother To Daughter And Back By Rebus

March 2023
2min read

The story behind the curious and delicately drawn riddles which appear on these pages began when the long lines of General John Burgoyne’s sullen British troops marched out of camp to stack their arms and ammunition in a meadow not far from Saratoga, New York. The staggering news of Burgoyne’s defeat brought France into the war against Great Britain, and George III decided, early in February of 1778, that the only way out of this dilemma was to withdraw most of the British armies from America and employ them with the navy against French and Spanish settlements.

To do this, he authorixed Lord North to offer the rebels everything they wanted—except independence. In the midst of the heated debates that followed Lord North’s conciliatory proposals, the appointment of five British peace commissioners, and the Continental Congress’ determined stand against any such nonsense, an Englishman named Matthew Darly produced the two little rebuses illustrated here. Darly was a London engraver and caricaturist, loyal to the Crown, but in these two charming letters he summed up with unusual insight what people felt, at the particular moment in history, on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean.

The rebus as a form of communication dates back to earliest times, when its function was to give a word a visible symbol which would take the place of writing. Among earliest examples are signboards used in ancient Egypt and in Herculaneum and Pompeii. The French first made the rebus into a kind of riddle, and it became a form of amusement for generations of adults and children in France, England, and America.

Translation of Rebuses on Pages 44 and 45

England to America

My dear Daughter I cannot behold without great pain your headstrong backwardness to return to your Duty in not opposing all the good I long intended for your sole Happiness and being told that you have given your hand to a [undeciphered] and two-faced man I have sent you five over wise men the greatest of all my children to put you to rights and hope you will listen to them and mind what they say to you they have instructions to give you those things you formerly required so be a good girl discharge your soldiers and ships of war and do not rebel against your mother rely upon me and do not consult [ ? ] to what that French Rascal shall tell you I see he wants to bring on an enmity to all unity between you and I but listen not to him all the world takes notice of his two faces I’ll send him such Messages from my great cannons as shall make his heart repent and know that one good or ill turn merits another. NB let not [undeciphered] take too much hold of your heart.

I am your friend and mother.

America to her mistaken mother

You silly old woman that you have sent a dove to us is very plain to draw our attention from our real interests but we are determined to abide by our own ways of thinking your five children you have sent to us shall be treated as Visitors and safely sent home again you may consult [ ? ] them and admire them but you must not expect one of your puppets will come home to you as sweet as you sent him, twas cruel to send so pretty a man so many thousand miles and to have the fatigue of returning back after bobbing his coat and dirtying those reddened shoes if you are wise follow your own advice you gave to me take home your warships [and] soldiers guard well your own triflings and leave me to my self as I am at age to know my own interests without your foolish advice and know that I shall always regard you and my Brothers as relations but not as friends

I am your greatly injured

Daughter America.

We hope you enjoy our work.

Please support this 72-year tradition of trusted historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it with a donation to American Heritage.


Stories published from "December 1956"

Authored by: Louise Hall Tharp

Mrs. Howe jotted down the “Battle Hymn” in haste, but she lived to hear a nation sing it, and went to her grave to its tune

Authored by: Paul M. Angle

Some became great, others stayed as they were-- and their story tells of the rise of the Midwest

Authored by: David Herbert Donald

One of the saddest tales in American history tells how a well-intentioned President lost a dazzling opportunity

Authored by: Archibald MacLeish

From his great-grandfather’s papers a poet re-creates that hard-working man of many parts—sailor, farmer, merchant financier—the New England sea captain

Authored by: John Dos Passos

Washington was his idol, but he could not apply his American ideals to a France sliding into the Terror

Authored by: Fairfax Downey

It’s the sort of thing that couldn’t happen now, but in the Revolution Molly Corbin and Molly Pitcher were first-rate cannoneers

Authored by: D. Jay Culver

A special supplement prepared for American Heritage

A cultivated and subtle musical art form nourished the Puritans in the wilderness

Authored by: Fred C. Kelly

If its day was brief, it raised the hem, leveled the classes, and widened a generation’s horizons

Authored by: E. Alexander Powell

Brilliant Benjamin Thompson won world fame as Count Rumford the scientist but never dispelled his countrymen’s suspicions

Featured Articles

The world’s most prominent actress risked her career by standing up to one of Hollywood’s mega-studios, proving that behind the beauty was also a very savvy businesswoman. 

Rarely has the full story been told about how a famed botanist, a pioneering female journalist, and First Lady Helen Taft battled reluctant bureaucrats to bring Japanese cherry trees to Washington. 

Often thought to have been a weak president, Carter was strong-willed in doing what he thought was right, regardless of expediency or the political fallout.

Why have thousands of U.S. banks failed over the years? The answers are in our history and politics.

In his Second Inaugural Address, Abraham Lincoln embodied leading in a time of polarization, political disagreement, and differing understandings of reality.