Skip to main content

Judgments

March 2023
1min read


Regarding Dr. Fawn M. Brodie’s article “I Think Hiss Is Lying” (August/ September 1981):

Indeed the Hiss-Chambers controversy does continue. Ultimately history will judge it; however, that judgment must derive from facts rather than assumptions, speculation, or innuendo. It would be well, then, to address and refute the following errors of fact in the Brodie piece:

That Hiss was exposed as a spy by Chambers—and as early as 1939.

Brodie says that Chambers “in 1939 had blown Hiss’s cover as an espionage agent by going to Adolph Berle with his story. …” But according to both FBI records and Berle’s own notes on that meeting, such an exposé never took place.

It was Elizabeth Terrill Bentley, another self-confessed Communist, who in November, 1945, spoke of a connection between Hiss and espionage. “It should be noted,” says an FBI report dated January 28, 1949, “that Miss Bentley’s allegations were the first indication received by the FBI that a Soviet espionage ring had existed in Washington.”

That Chambers had threatened to make his Hiss charges public as early as 1945.

According to Brodie, Chambers had “watched with increasing anxiety the rise of Alger Hiss in government … [and] told FBI men … that if Hiss was made temporary Secretary General of the United Nations” he would expose [Hiss] publicly.”

Not only had Chambers told the FBI he had not been following Hiss’s career, but a search of FBI records for 1945 nowhere indicates Chambers had threatened such an exposé.

Further, Chambers really did not want to “go public.” According to an FBI statement dated March 29, 1946, Chambers said he “would have no objection to testifying …hoped that if such an occasion arose, it would be a closed hearing as he wanted to protect his identity. ” Is this the position of a Don Quixote?

That after extensive FBI surveillance of Hiss, the State Department quietly eased him out of his job.

While many in the State Department were relieved to see Hiss leave, no evidence supports the assertion that he was eased out. In fact, according to a September 10, 1948, FBI memorandum, both Secretary of State James Byrnes and Dean Acheson were surprised to learn of his departure.

Although I disagree with many of Dr. Brodie’s conclusions, I have only challenged those assertions that are incorrect based on recently released FBI documents.

We hope you enjoy our work.

Please support this 72-year tradition of trusted historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it with a donation to American Heritage.

Donate

Stories published from "June/july 1982"

Authored by: Paul Lancaster

You’d never recognize it today. Perhaps this will refresh your memory.

Authored by: The Editors

Victorian art, collected for patriotism and profit, finds a home in a New York hotel 19

Authored by: Dyan Zaslowsky

Before there were Western states, there were public lands—over a billion acres irrevocably reserved for the people of the United States. The Sagebrush Rebels are the most recent in a series of covetous groups bent on “regaining” what was never theirs.

Authored by: Martha Saxton

How Juliette “Daisy” Low, an unwanted child, a miserable wife, a lonely widow, finally found happiness as the founder of the Girl Scouts of America

Authored by: Stephen B. Oates

A century after passage of the Fifteenth Amendment, many Southern blacks still were denied the vote. In 1965 Martin Luther King, Jr, set out to change that—by marching through the heart of Alabama.

Authored by: Wayne Barrett

Buried here, along with hundreds of congressmen and various Indian chiefs, are Mathew Brady, John Philip Sousa, and J. Edgar Hoover

Authored by: E. McClung Fleming

… on its 200th anniversary. It took six years and seven tries—by such men as Franklin, Jefferson, and Adams—to come up with the official symbol of the United States. But what in the world does it mean?

Authored by: Kay Sloan

Was it science, sport, or the prospect of a round-the-world railroad that sent the tycoon off on his costly Alaskan excursion?

Authored by: Ken Auletta

In a new book, the political journalist and columnist Richard Reeves retraces Alexis de Tocqueville’s remarkable 1831-32 journey through America. Reeves's conclusion: Tocqueville not only deserves his reputation as the greatest observer of our democracy—he is an incomparable guide to what is happening in our country now.

Authored by: John Keegan

A British schoolboy sees the quiet English countryside come alive with excitement toward the end of 1943 when …

Featured Articles

The world’s most prominent actress risked her career by standing up to one of Hollywood’s mega-studios, proving that behind the beauty was also a very savvy businesswoman. 

Rarely has the full story been told about how a famed botanist, a pioneering female journalist, and First Lady Helen Taft battled reluctant bureaucrats to bring Japanese cherry trees to Washington. 

Often thought to have been a weak president, Carter was strong-willed in doing what he thought was right, regardless of expediency or the political fallout.

Why have thousands of U.S. banks failed over the years? The answers are in our history and politics.

In his Second Inaugural Address, Abraham Lincoln embodied leading in a time of polarization, political disagreement, and differing understandings of reality.