Skip to main content

Mary Baker Eddy: Another View

March 2023
3min read

The Committee on Publications of the First Church of Christ, Scientist, has recently offered us a commentary on Dr. Julius Silberger, Jr. ‘s article on Mary Baker Eddy, founder of the religion, which appeared in our December 1980 issue:

“One thing on which Mrs. Eddy’s admirers and critics agree is that she was a ‘remarkable’ woman. The fact that she founded a major American religious movement in an age and at an age when she might have been expected, in her own ironic words, to be a little old lady in a lace cap, justifies at least that much of a generalization.

“But remarkable people are more often than not complex. And when their lives are as long as Mrs. Eddy’s was (she lived from 1821 to 1910) they often change in remarkable ways, becoming virtually several different people in the course of their evolving experience. This makes it all the more necessary to avoid winding the threads of such a life onto the single spool of one’s own interests and assumptions.

“As a practicing psychiatrist, Dr. Silberger naturally tries to account for Mrs. Eddy’s life and motivation in terms of psychological factors of professional interest to him. Such a sketch expectably conveys the impression of a woman driven by personal and emotional needs against the background of nineteenth-century American social conditions. But it is important to remember that these conditions included strong religious influences—especially in rural New England where the Puritan spirit was still very much alive during Mrs. Eddy’s youth. The evidence bearing on her religious motivation is both plentiful and essential.

“One need not be a believer in her teaching or even in Christianity itself to see that realism in biography does not, cannot, exclude the religious dimension of human life. That was the attitude of the facile iconoclasm in biographical writing which flourished a half-century or more ago (the period, incidentally, when there first appeared the ‘debunking’ accounts of Mrs. Eddy’s life upon which later psychobiographers have drawn). But an interdisciplinary approach generally opts for some understanding of the fuller dimensions of the subject.

“With an insight into the human spirit born of his own experience as a survivor of Auschwitz, psychiatrist Viktor E. Frankl has written, ‘… humanity has demonstrated ad nauseam in recent years that it has instincts, drives. Today it appears more important to remind man that he has a spirit, that he is a spiritual being.’ Frankl is not speaking of preoccupation with religion in the conventional sense but of that profound concern with the meaning of life which is an irreducible part of the human spirit.

“Mrs. Eddy’s wrestlings with this question simply cannot be excluded from any meaningful account of her life and struggles. The problem of evil presented itself to her in girlhood in terms of the stark Calvinist doctrine of predestination, against which she rebelled with all the force of her youthful nature. It confronted her anew in the form of the loss and desolation that overshadowed her middle years. And through the whole first half of her life it pressed itself upon her intermittently in the physical sufferings and nervous debility to which she was so often subject. Decades of adversity forced her to consider the question in a way that far transcended the limits of her personal experience and broke radically with the conventional theology of the day.

“No less a psychologist than Gordon Allport has warned against the ‘error of the psychoanalytic theory of religion’ which locates ‘religious belief exclusively in the defensive functions of the ego. Mrs. Eddy’s real achievement was not to have made a personal ‘success’ of a life that for the first forty-five years brimmed over with disappointments. Rather, it was to have found in the Bible a transforming insight into the meaning of life that enabled her to develop a practical theology which grappled with the age-long problem of evil.

“Long before Auschwitz, acutely troubled souls had been asking, ‘Can God really be good—can there even be a God at all—when emptiness, agony, and human brutality are so often the human lot?’ The answer that Mrs. Eddy found in the life of Jesus Christ was that evil of every sort was no part of God’s creative will, no part of the true spiritual order of His universe, and that this truth understood could begin at once to lift the burden of evil from experience.

“However, she insisted that such an understanding could be incorporated into living only through radical Christian discipleship; it was, she held, a far cry from the exercise of will power, blind faith, or a manipulative mental technique. To the end of her days she counted herself (as she figuratively put it) a ‘willing disciple at the heavenly gate, waiting for the Mind of Christ.’ Her writings refer frankly to the intense struggles she went through in carrying out what she felt to be her mission, and nowhere did she claim to be humanly perfect or the equal of Jesus. Certainly it’s untrue to say that she expected not to die, whatever some of her overzealous followers may have hoped for.

“No more than the life of a Jonathan Edwards, a Mother Mary Seton, or a Martin Luther King, Jr., can Mrs. Eddy’s life be separated from the religious purpose that dominated it. Indeed, it is only by transcending their own purely personal concerns and involving themselves passionately with man’s quest for meaning that any such figures attain the status which history—sometimes reluctantly—grants them.”

We hope you enjoy our work.

Please support this 72-year tradition of trusted historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it with a donation to American Heritage.


Stories published from "February/March 1982"

Authored by: Carmine A. Prioli

In the shadow of Bunker Hill, bigots perpetrated an atrocity that showed a shocked nation that the fires of the Reformation still burned in the New World

Authored by: Charles B. Strozier

To stave off despair, the President relied on a sense of humor that was rich, self-deprecating—and surprisingly bawdy

Authored by: The Editors

about foreign policy, his opponent, the voters, and the polls

Authored by: The Editors

and plans a counterattack

Authored by: The Editors

The Combat Art of Albert K. Murray

Authored by: Oscar V. Armstrong

Once again, Americans are learning the delicate art of trading with the biggest market on earth. Here’s how they did it the first time.

Authored by: James Wunsch

—More than a century ago, the city of St. Louis enacted a well-thought-out plan to legalize vice. What went wrong? Everything .

Authored by: The Editors

The sad story of a magazine born eighty years too soon

Authored by: The Editors

Far from home and in the face of every kind of privation, the Civil War soldier did his best to re-create the world he left behind him

Featured Articles

Famous writers including Emerson, Thoreau, Hawthorne, and the Alcotts turned Sleepy Hollow Cemetery into our country’s first conservation project.

Native American peoples and the lands they possessed loomed large for Washington, from his first trips westward as a surveyor to his years as President.

In his Second Inaugural Address, Abraham Lincoln embodied leading in a time of polarization, political disagreement, and differing understandings of reality.

A hundred years ago, America was rocked by riots, repression, and racial violence.

During Pres. Washington’s first term, an epidemic killed one tenth of all the inhabitants of Philadelphia, then the capital of the young United States.

Now a popular state park, the unassuming geological feature along the Illinois River has served as the site of centuries of human habitation and discovery.  

The recent discovery of the hull of the battleship Nevada recalls her dramatic action at Pearl Harbor and ultimate revenge on D-Day as the first ship to fire on the Nazis.

Our research reveals that 19 artworks in the U.S. Capitol honor men who were Confederate officers or officials. What many of them said, and did, is truly despicable.

Here is probably the most wide-ranging look at Presidential misbehavior ever published in a magazine.

When Germany unleashed its blitzkreig in 1939, the U.S. Army was only the 17th largest in the world. FDR and Marshall had to build a fighting force able to take on the Nazis, against the wishes of many in Congress.

Roast pig, boiled rockfish, and apple pie were among the dishes George and Martha enjoyed during the holiday in 1797. Here are some actual recipes.

Born during Jim Crow, Belle da Costa Greene perfected the art of "passing" while working for one of the most powerful men in America.