Skip to main content

Overrated? Underrated?

July 2026
1min read


I couldn’t agree more with Ellen Handler Spitz’s choices for the most overrated and underrated children’s classics. However, I wish that she had mentioned that there are now two excellent alternate versions of Little Black Sambo . Sam and the Tigers , rewritten by Julius Lester, was published by Dial, and The Story of Little Babaji was published by HarperCollins, both in 1996. These books eliminate the offensive stereotypes in language and illustration of the original version.

Help us tell the story of America.

For over 75 years, American Heritage has chronicled our nation's history like no other publication. Please support our trusted, non-partisan historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it by donating today. We rely on contributions from readers like you to survive.
Donate