Skip to main content

Debt To The Immigrant

March 2023
2min read

In a sense, all of us are immigrants. Our roots go back beyond the water; our fathers, or our ultimate great-grandfathers, once took the long chance, got on a ship, and came to the New World. So what comes of it all? What sort of nation do we have, how has the fact that our roots go beyond the sea affected what has been done in this country?

It is always good to get a fresh point of view, and this is provided by Mr. Frank Thistlethwaite, a certified Cambridge don, in his new book The Great Experiment , which is a concise and neatly written attempt to explain the bewildering United States to English readers. It may also have the useful function of helping to explain us to ourselves.

The British, says Mr. Thistlethwaite, entertain odd misconceptions about America. They suspect that it is still a branch of Europe; they believe that it will presently accept this fact, drift around somehow to a British parliamentary government, and in other ways will behave as proper children of northwestern Europe ought to behave. The British want to know, mostly, “Why do Americans regard themselves as a special sort of people?” In this book Mr. Thistlethwaite undertakes to explain matters.

The Great Experiment: An Introduction to the History of the American People , by Frank Thistlethwaite. Cambridge University Press. 335 pp. $5.

One set of influences, he believes, has dominated American development—the influences that come from migration. These have brought about on our shores “a new variant of western society.” All of us have been uprooted; consequently, despite the cultural heritage we have brought with us, we developed an entirely new set of values. There is a deep psychological contrast. The American version of Western society is something new, which Mr. Thistlethwaite defines, quite simply, as “the mobile society.”

It is mobile in that nothing stays fixed. The act of immigration meant a rejection of custom. “In a sense,” says Mr. Thistlethwaite, “each new immigrant arriving at Castle Garden was already more American than the native-born son of the Republic in that he himself had shown the will to make a clean break with the past.” He was coming to the land where anything goes.

Nothing stayed fixed, and so the western frontier finally vanished, and then unrestricted immigration itself came to an end. But the mobility remained; for just as the forces which might have created a static society became dominant, the great catalyst of mass production appeared, offering a new frontier in an undiscovered dimension. It intensified the drive that the old frontier situation had begun; the mobility which conditioned American growth during the period of the great migration was extended; and so, says Mr. Thistlethwaite, “the social compulsions of the caravan have continued in important ways to govern American habit.”

Thus the original impetus still holds good. In the middle of the Twentieth Century, the American people are still pursuing the ideal which shaped the Revolution itself. And that, specifically, is what?

It is, says this English student, “a Republic established in the belief that men of good will could voluntarily come together in the sanctuary of an American wilderness to order their common affairs according to rational principles.” It is an association of people bonded together by free choice rather than by destiny; a community of people “for whom the individual conscience alone is sovereign"; a society, in short, of people uprooted by their own choice, people who have thrown off the authoritative traditions and customs of the past, people who are forever on the move, creating a fluid society which is tied to no rigid values and which seeks the promise of the future by an implicit rejection of the past.

This, as Mr. Thistlethwaite remarks, is “the most ambitious ideal ever to command the allegiance of a great nation,” and it remains to be seen how it will finally pan out. We are a people who have elected to shoot the works. It is all or nothing, with us. Our concept of nationality is basically revolutionary, and we do not yet know for sure how it will fit into the responsibilities that go with a great power and a self-assertive form of nationalism. And he concludes, finally, that Walt Whitman said it, once and for all: “The United States are destined either to surmount the gorgeous history of feudalism or else prove the most tremendous failure of time.”

We hope you enjoy our work.

Please support this 72-year tradition of trusted historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it with a donation to American Heritage.


Stories published from "October 1955"

Authored by: John Walton

John Filson first brought the frontier hero to notice, giving him fine words that made him the idol of the romanticists

Authored by: Eric Sloane

An artist recalls the picturesque devices that helped a young nation get ready for the age of machinery

Authored by: Alan Villiers

The clippers were beautiful, fast, too expensive to endure long—and a perfect expression of a great American urge

Authored by: Wallace Stegner

How the Saskatchewan-Montana prairie country looked a generation ago, and what it meant to a youngster who lived there

Authored by: Richard Moody

Brought to the stage without her consent, this enduring American drama did not bring the author a cent—but it gave actors a living for generations

Authored by: John Maass

Despite lapses in taste and confusion as to style the Nineteenth-Century architect knew that he was doing, and often did it well

Authored by: George Dangerfield

Spokesman for a rising industrialism, this prime minister bid for free trade with the United States and helped to create something quite different

Authored by: Alvin Harlow

Matthew Lyon did not like John Adams, and insisted on his right to say so. He spent months in jail but he could not be silenced.

Authored by: Cedric A. Larson

Most terrible steamboat disaster in history, probably, was the loss of the Sultana in 1865. Some 1,700 returning Union veterans died—yet the tragedy got very few headlines.

Authored by: The Editors

A recently discovered sketchbook of Lewis Miller

Featured Articles

Rarely has the full story been told about how a famed botanist, a pioneering female journalist, and First Lady Helen Taft battled reluctant bureaucrats to bring Japanese cherry trees to Washington. 

The world’s most prominent actress risked her career by standing up to one of Hollywood’s mega-studios, proving that behind the beauty was also a very savvy businesswoman. 

Often thought to have been a weak president, Carter was strong-willed in doing what he thought was right, regardless of expediency or the political fallout.

Why have thousands of U.S. banks failed over the years? The answers are in our history and politics.

In his Second Inaugural Address, Abraham Lincoln embodied leading in a time of polarization, political disagreement, and differing understandings of reality.