Overrated & Underrated

July 2026
1min read

Is Robert E. Lee getting a free ride? Is it time someone spoke up for Richard Nixon? And does anyone have the lonely courage to say that most barbecue is greasy filth? There are exaggerated reputations in every field of American history, and overlooked ones, too. We asked the experts to choose which is which.

 

 

Help us tell the story of America.

For over 75 years, American Heritage has chronicled our nation's history like no other publication. Please support our trusted, non-partisan historical writing and the volunteers that sustain it by donating today. We rely on contributions from readers like you to survive.
Donate

Related stories

Special Issue: What Made America Great

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
For our 75th Anniversary, we asked leading historians to look at some of the principles and great accomplishments that have defined our Nation.

The American States

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
The greater part of our national heritage is to be found in the record of our States. From the study of that record we can gain a renewal of our most precious possession, faith in the national ideal.

Our American Heritage 

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
This magazine will be devoted to the great task of bringing history to the people as a foundation for a stronger Americanism.

A Celebration of Our Heritage

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
Friends of American Heritage gathered to celebrate 75 years of great writing and education about our nation's history.

Some of Our Favorite Essays

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
Nearly 2,500 historians and authors have told the story of America in the pages of our magazine

Our Readers' Favorite Articles of 2023

by Edwin S. Grosvenor

Sam Holt, Pioneer of Public Broadcasting

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
Holt helped create PBS and National Public Radio before becoming chairman of American Heritage.

Remembering David McCullough

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
He became the dean of American historians after learning his craft while working for five years on the staff of American Heritage.

Recovery Efforts at American Heritage

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
It was a challenging couple of months after the flood, but our office will soon be operational again.

2020 Articles by Author

by Edwin S. Grosvenor
A convenient index to the nearly 100 articles in American Heritage in 2020

About American Heritage

For 75 years, American Heritage has been the leading magazine of U.S. history, politics, and culture. Read more about the magazine >>

The magazine was forced to suspend print publication in 2013, but a group of volunteers saved the archives and relaunched the magazine in digital form in 2017. Free subscription >>  

American Heritage is published by the National Historical Society,  a non-partisan 501(c)3 membership society. Please consider a donation to help us keep this American treasure alive. Support with a donation >>

FIND US ON SOCIAL MEDIA

© Copyright 1949-2025 American Heritage Publishing Co. All Rights Reserved. To license content, please contact licenses [at] americanheritage.com.

AMERICAN HERITAGE
Trusted Writing on History, Travel, and American Culture Since 1949
 
X